Luther Vandross Reportedly Smiled When Turning Down Babyface’s “Every Time I Close My Eyes”

Babyface‘s hit 1996 ballad “Every Time I Close My Eyes” was almost part of Luther Vandross‘ catalog.

The crooner took to Instagram on Monday (Sept. 8) sharing a photo of “the exact moment Luther said no to singing ‘Every Time I Close My Eyes.’”

Babyface admitted, “[It was] probably the best rejection I ever got because it became one of my biggest records…. But I still wish he would have sung it!”

Fans were tickled at the thought of Vandross saying no with a huge grin on his face— which would be very fitting. In light of the fun fact, one fan requested, “I’d love for you to one day release all the demos of you singing hits you gave to other artists!”

Meanwhile, others agreed that “[‘Every Time I Close My Eyes’] had Luther written all over it!”

“Every Time I Close My Eyes” was written, produced, and performed by Face. Mariah Carey was the featured artist along with Kenny G, who played saxophone. It was the second single from his fourth studio album, The Day. The Grammy-nominated record peaked No. 6 on the Billboard Hot 100 and No. 5 on the Billboard Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs charts.

Years later, Babyface co-wrote “Grown Thangs” with Jon B for Vandross’ eponymous 2001 LP. Jon B produced the record and both men appeared on its backing vocals. That album was Vandross’ J Records label debut, but his 13th overall studio album. It also featured his hit modern-day single, “Take You Out.”